There’s been a lot of discussion recently, amid Uta Frith’s reflections, about whether the autism spectrum has become too vague – a culturally amplified identity rather than a precise clinical diagnosis. Pitching ‘real’ autism against the ‘societal version’ of people who just find the social and emotional demands of everyday life a bit overwhelming. And let’s be honest, in this edgy, defensive, isolated, AI-powered world we’re living in – who doesn’t?
And I do agree with
her, to a point. A high-functioning autistic person (as my husband and children
are) who, it’s fairly clear, have some difficulties around processing, sensory
issues, socialisation and understanding emotion, are not in the same league as,
say, non-verbal extreme autistics who may need help and intervention to do even
the most basic tasks like getting dressed, toileting and communicating needs.
But herein lies the
rub.
Classically autistic
people (and please excuse my phrasing here, I’m no expert in the precise
terminology – which seems to change constantly – I just want to
communicate as simply as I can) generally aren’t expected to compete on a
common playing field with everyone else. They often attend specialist schools,
live in sheltered accommodation and, if they do work, are employed on the
understanding of their diagnosis and limitations.
High-functioning
autistics – so high that they can, to a certain extent and for a certain
time, mask their differences – are expected to compete in the same
world, on the same terms and to achieve the same outcomes as neurotypical
people who don’t have the same challenges.
And that’s hard.
In that sense, the
autism diagnosis isn’t serving anyone – too broad for those people who
are ‘really autistic’ – many of whose families claim they are being
forgotten amid high-achieving autistics who can, and often do, advocate for
themselves. But also becoming meaningless in day-to-day life for
high-functioning autistics, many of whom still have very few accommodations
made for them and are expected to live, work, relate and achieve in the same
way as everyone else.
Autistic and overlooked
Take my husband’s work
situation, for example.
He’s great at his job
and has a natural talent for what he does – to a large extent fed by his
autistic brain, which learns visually, notices detail and can hyperfixate on
the job at hand.
What he can’t do very
well is communicate effectively, stay focused in meetings, express what he’s
thinking or feeling, relate to other people, pick up on unspoken messaging and
societal rules, remember people’s names or manage his emotions.
He’s been lucky, in
that he started his career path at a time when, even with just one GCSE in art,
you could work your way up if you knuckled down and had talent. And,
thankfully, he’s been able to stay more-or-less in that role with that company
for the last 25 years (because another thing he doesn’t cope well with is
change).
But what I have seen
happen, again and again, is how he’s overlooked for opportunities, promotion
and special projects.
A few months ago, in an
appraisal, Ethan was given the impression he could take on a special project
off-site. Ethan took this off-hand remark, from someone with no involvement in
the project, to mean that he would definitely be the project lead. He did nothing
to consolidate or confirm that casual conversation or get himself involved –
just waited quietly to be called on.
Meanwhile, another
sociable employee who is fun to be with, knows the importance of (and crucially
has the skills to) build relationships, is quick-witted and knows the right
things to say and when, got himself involved in early discussions with the team,
ensured he was liked and, unsurprisingly, was given the lead role on the
project.
Jury service for
autistics
A similar thing has
been taking place over the last fortnight.
A couple of months ago,
Ethan received a letter in the post informing him he’d been selected for jury
service.
For his autistic brain,
this came with many challenges:
- a change to his routine
- having to take public transport to
get to court
- the unknown element – what
would be expected of him? What would his days look like?
- having to stay focused for long
periods and communicate with people he didn’t know
However, he processed
all of this and, on the day he left for jury duty, was nervous but also
slightly excited to get started.
But his last day of
jury duty is today – and he’s been told not to bother going in.
With more potential
jurors than jury spaces, Ethan has spent every day of the last two weeks ‘on
the bench’ – forced to relive the soul-destroying feeling of being the
kid nobody wants when classmates pick teams in PE.
The thing is, I get
it.

If I were picking jurors, I’d go for the people who looked ‘turned on’ – attentive, interested, engaged, pleasant, intelligent even. I wouldn’t pick the person with a continually disdainful look on his face (I know that, unfortunately, this is just Ethan’s autistic resting face and doesn’t necessarily reflect what’s going on inside, but other people don’t). I’d also look at how prospective jurors were interacting and would, generally speaking, go for the people who were – well, interacting – and looking like they’d have something to contribute to a guilty or innocent discussion.
All those things mean I
probably wouldn’t pick Ethan.
The most frustrating
thing is, he’d have been great. His analytical mind, attention to detail and
ability to detach from his emotions would have served the jury well.
And this brings me back
to my point – it’s all very well to say that the autistic diagnosis
should be reserved for those who, clearly, struggle the most to ‘get on’ in our
world. But then maybe we need to come up with a new diagnosis for the people
who are autistic but can, to a certain extent, come across as ‘normal’. This
may not cause the same degree of problems that low-functioning autistic people
face, but it does create a whole new set of problems which should not be
dismissed lightly.




